From Stove to Scale: Lessons for Small Pet Businesses on Growing Safely

From Stove to Scale: What Pet-Treat Startups Must Learn from Liber & Co.'s Rise

Hook: You started by testing batches on a kitchen counter — now you face tanks, trucks, and regulators. Scaling production for a pet treat startup brings exciting growth but also new risks: recalls, labeling audits, supplier failures, and liability claims that can sink a small brand overnight. Learn the practical, insurance-smart quality steps Liber & Co. used (and the gaps many DIY founders miss) so you can grow safer and smarter in 2026.

“It all started with a single pot on a stove.” — Chris Harrison, Liber & Co.

The big idea: why Liber & Co. matters to pet-food founders

Liber & Co. began as a hands-on, DIY beverage syrups brand and scaled into 1,500-gallon tanks and global distribution while keeping much of manufacturing in-house. That journey mirrors many pet-food and treat founders—passion-driven, taste-first, bootstrap-funded. Their advantages—tight product knowledge, close control of ingredients, and a strong brand voice—are huge. But as volume, channels, and geographic reach expand, the informal rules that worked in a kitchen won’t protect you against food-safety incidents, labeling violations, or product liability in 2026’s stricter regulatory landscape.

Top lessons from Liber & Co. for pet treat startups

1. Translate your DIY culture into documented systems

Liber & Co. kept a do-it-yourself culture as they scaled, handling manufacturing, warehousing, and e-commerce in-house. That culture is a strength — it creates ownership and rapid iteration — but it must become repeatable.

• Action: For every critical task (mixing, batching, packaging, cleaning), create a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) within your first 6 months of scale. Include step-by-step instructions, critical limits, and responsible roles. If you want examples from brands that scaled packaging and retail tactics, see this packaging and branding case study.
• Why it matters: SOPs reduce human error, speed training, and are essential evidence for audits and insurance claims. For field-ready tech and packing checklists for pop-up retail, consult a field toolkit review.

2. Invest early in traceability and lot coding

When Liber & Co. moved to large tanks, batch ID and traceability became crucial. Pet-food recalls can escalate quickly; traceability narrows the scope and cost of a response.

• Action: Implement a lot-coding standard from day one. Make codes human- and machine-readable (e.g., YYMMDD-PLANT-BATCH). Scan every inbound raw material and outbound finished good. For smaller brands looking at sustainable packaging and micro-fulfilment, this scaling playbook covers traceability touchpoints for packaging and fulfillment.
• Tools: Start with a simple inventory management system that supports batch numbers; plan to adopt GS1-compliant barcodes or EPCIS when you reach multi-state distribution.

3. Formalize supplier qualification and incoming testing

Scaling means relying on more suppliers. Liber & Co. kept sourcing tight, but pet-food formulas require documented supplier control.

• Action: Create supplier approval checklists: certifications (GMP, HACCP), COAs (Certificates of Analysis), audit history, and insurance limits. Require COAs for each raw-material lot for at least the first 12 months with a new supplier. If you sell botanicals or specialty extracts, keep an eye on industry recall trends and guidance in this product quality alerts & recalls guide.
• Action: Implement an incoming testing plan for high-risk ingredients (meat meals, botanical extracts, novel proteins). Use third-party labs for microbiology and contaminants (salmonella, listeria, mycotoxins, heavy metals).

4. Adopt a preventive controls mindset (FSMA & pet food)

Under the Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA), many pet-food manufacturers must have a Preventive Controls Qualified Individual (PCQI) and a written Food Safety Plan. Even if you’re small, the preventive approach reduces risk.

• Action: Train at least one PCQI (online or instructor-led) and document your hazard analysis, preventive controls, monitoring, corrective actions, verification, and recordkeeping. For small teams juggling training and onboarding, CRM and operations tools can help manage training tasks—see guidance on using CRMs to manage onboarding workstreams in this CRM onboarding guide.
• Why it matters: Regulators and insurers increasingly evaluate whether a business follows preventive controls when assessing compliance and premiums.

5. Make labeling a compliance and marketing win

Label errors are a frequent source of enforcement and consumer complaints. Liber & Co.’s meticulous brand-first approach can be adapted for pet products.

• Required elements: Ingredient list, net weight, manufacturer name/address, batch or lot code, feeding directions, guaranteed analysis (for certain products), and any required cautionary statements (e.g., choking hazards for certain shapes/sizes).
• Action: Implement a label review checklist that includes regulatory checks (FDA/CVM and AAFCO guidance), claims substantiation, allergen declarations, and a final pre-press proof read. Use a third-party label reviewer for your first major retail launch and consult resources on photographing and documenting product claims professionally in this ethical photographer’s guide.
• Trust signals: Display certifications (e.g., SQF, BRC), third-party lab results, and QR codes linking to batch test reports and ingredient origin stories. These are powerful trust signals on e-commerce pages and retailer listings—see ideas for live-sell and community commerce signals in this community commerce guide.

Quality control: practical steps to scale safely

Design your QC program in phases

Scaling doesn’t mean you must build a full QA lab overnight. Liber & Co. scaled capability as needs grew — you can too.

1. Phase 1 — Foundational (0–12 months retail): SOPs, lot codes, supplier COAs, basic in-house checks (pH, water activity, weight), a recall plan template. For physical pop-up readiness and field tech, the pop-up tech field guide lists compact gear and workflows that help maintain QC in temporary retail settings.
2. Phase 2 — Growth (12–36 months): Formalized incoming testing, routine third-party microbiology sampling, shelf-life and stability testing, packaging integrity checks. Brands that scaled packaging and retail execution documented these in their case studies—see a recent microbrand packaging case study.
3. Phase 3 — Enterprise (36+ months): Full QC lab or dedicated QA team, third-party certification (SQF/BRC/ISO 22000), ERP with traceability, batch-level consumer communication tools (QR codes, blockchain pilots).

Testing cadence and what to test

High-level guidance you can act on now:

• Incoming materials: COA review every lot; microbiology for high-risk items every lot for first 3 months, then 1:10 lots if supplier stable.
• Finished product: Microbial screens (salmonella, enterobacteriaceae) and physical checks on each batch for the first 100 production runs; then sample testing per production volume (e.g., 1% of batches) once validated.
• Shelf-life: Conduct real-time and accelerated stability testing early — this avoids costly reformulations after retailers demand a specific shelf life.

Insurance and liability: how to protect your growing business

As Liber & Co.’s volume and channel mix grew, so did their exposure. For pet treat startups, insurance isn’t optional — it’s a growth enabler.

Core insurance coverages for pet-food/treat makers

• General liability: Basic protection for bodily injury and property damage on-premises.
• Product liability: Essential — covers claims from contaminated or harmful products. Ask for limits that match retail and distributor contracts.
• Product recall insurance: Covers the cost of recall logistics, communications, disposal, and some remediation. Increasingly affordable and critical given modern recall speeds.
• Commercial property & business interruption: Protects equipment, inventory, and lost income from shutdowns.
• Cyber insurance: For DTC brands: covers breach of customer data and e-commerce interruptions.
• Workers' compensation: Required if you have employees; protects against workplace injuries.

What insurers look for — and how to lower premiums

Insurers won’t just look at revenue. They examine your controls.

• Quality programs: Documented SOPs, PCQI training, testing records, and recall plans reduce perceived risk.
• Traceability: Lot codes and supplier records shorten recall scope and lower claims costs.
• Third-party audits or certifications: SQF/BRC or documented third-party lab testing can materially improve terms.

Practical insurance actions

1. Talk to an insurer that specializes in food manufacturing and pet products. General brokers may miss class-specific exposures.
2. Bundle product liability and recall insurance where possible; carriers often offer better pricing combined.
3. Prepare documentation before applying: SOPs, supplier lists, COAs, recalls history (if any), and projected sales channels. This speeds underwriting and avoids coverage gaps.

Labeling, claims, and consumer trust in 2026

Late 2025 and early 2026 brought stronger consumer demand for transparency and regulators pushing traceability pilots. Here’s how to turn compliance into a competitive edge.

Use labels as trust platforms

• Claims substantiation: Avoid vague claims like “supports joint health” unless you have evidence or clear qualifiers. Keep structure/function or non-disease claims backed by data and steer clear of unapproved therapeutic claims.
• QR codes and batch pages: Link to batch-specific COAs, sourcing stories, and feeding guidance. This is now expected by many online-savvy customers and retailers.
• Allergen transparency: Disclose possible cross-contact risks prominently; this reduces customer complaints and regulatory scrutiny.

Ratings and reviews — provider reviews as trust signals

Provider reviews, third-party ratings, and verified customer feedback are among the strongest trust signals for pet owners. Liber & Co. retained a cult following by telling its origin story and ensuring quality — you can replicate that.

• Prompt for verified reviews: After purchase, send an automated email requesting a review and include a direct link to upload photos or videos of pets enjoying the treat. If you run pop-up events or local activations, a field toolkit review shows quick ways to collect visual reviews in-person.
• Use independent nutritionists: Commission third-party reviews from veterinary nutritionists and publish their reports or endorsements to strengthen trust.

Regulatory checklists for 2026 (quick reference)

Keep these checks handy as you scale:

• Determine whether FSMA preventive controls apply to your operation and appoint/train a PCQI.
• Confirm state feed law registration requirements for each state you ship into. Many states require feed/pet food registration and fees.
• Use AAFCO model labeling guidance for ingredient naming and nutritional statements where applicable; don’t substitute marketing terms for regulated statements.
• Retain 18–24 months of batch records, COAs, and production logs; regulators and insurers will ask for them post-incident.

Scaling decision roadmap: in-house vs co-packing

Every brand faces the in-house or co-packer decision. Liber & Co. kept much in-house, but that path requires capital and deep QA investment.

When to stay in-house

• You need tight recipe control and rapid iteration.
• You can invest in QA and traceability systems.
• Your margins allow capital investment in equipment and personnel.

When to co-pack

• You want to scale quickly without heavy CAPEX.
• You prefer predictable production costs and access to existing food-safety systems.
• Choose co-packers with pet-food experience, appropriate certifications, and clear liability carve-outs in the contract. If you’re testing micro-retail like pop-ups, the pop-up tech field guide helps identify co-packer-friendly setups for temporary events.

Actionable 90-day checklist for pet treat founders

1. Create or update SOPs for the top 8 production tasks.
2. Implement lot coding and upgrade your inventory system to record batch traceability.
3. Run a supplier audit/template and require COAs for high-risk materials.
4. Train a PCQI or enroll key staff in FSMA preventive controls training.
5. Obtain or renew product liability and recall insurance quotes; review policy exclusions and limits with a broker specializing in pet-food clients.
6. Build a label review checklist and schedule a pre-launch third-party review for your next SKU; check packaging case studies for real examples in this microbrand case study.
7. Set up public trust signals: third-party lab results page, nutritionist and training endorsements, and QR codes on packaging.

Final thoughts: grow with curiosity — but systematize quickly

Liber & Co.'s story is proof that deep product knowledge and a DIY ethos can launch a successful consumer brand. For pet-food startups, that same spirit must be married to documented processes, proactive quality controls, and the right insurance to survive inevitable bumps.

In 2026, consumers and retailers expect transparency, and regulators plus insurers reward brands that prove they’ve done the work. Turn your stove-top lessons into systems that travel with you to the tank and beyond.

Want the full toolkit?

Download our free Scaling Safely Toolkit for pet treat startups: an SOP template pack, a lab-testing calendar, a sample recall plan, and an insurance pre-underwriting checklist. Or get a tailored insurance review from pet-insurance.cloud to match coverage to your growth stage.

Call to action: Ready to scale without the scares? Get the toolkit and a free 20-minute insurance pre-check to see where you’re exposed and how to fix it before you ship your next batch.

Related Reading

• How Small Brands Scale: Lessons from a DIY Cocktail Syrup Start-Up
• Scaling Small: Micro-fulfilment, Sustainable Packaging, and Ops Playbooks
• Case Study: How a Keto Microbrand Scaled with Packaging, Pop-Ups and Predictive Inventory
• Wearables for Hair Health: Lessons from Natural Cycles’ Wristband for Tracking Postpartum Hair Loss and Hormonal Changes
• Template: SLA & Escalation Playbook for Hybrid Human-AI Task Workflows
• LEGO Building and Fine Motor Skills: How a 1000-Piece Set Helps (and When It’s Too Much)
• Limited-Edition 'Art Meets Football' Drops: What Makes a Jersey Worth Millions?
• Profile: Liber & Co. and the Rise of Artisanal Syrups for Foodservice and Home Kitchens